Both singers put forth a valiant effort during the performance finale on Tuesday, but only one of them could be crowned the fifteenth (and final) American Idol.
But the most dramatic moment came when host Ryan Seacrest – who is featured in the current issue of PEOPLE – gave one last pregnant pause before revealing the final winner of the Fox reality singing competition.
15:34 'American Idol': Lionel Richie, Charlie Puth in talks to join judges panel7
19:15 Federica Pellegrini’s Shocking Upset of Katie Ledecky Highlights Night Four in Budapest25
17:50 'American Idol' Wants Lionel Richie and Charlie Puth as Final Two Judges18
01:45 Uptown rabbi donating his kidney to a stranger22