I suspect most reaction to Peter Pan Live will be split down the middle by those who just absolutely adored it, and those who hated it. People so often love to say something was The Best thing they've ever seen, or The Worst. And this production lends itself to hyperbole in either direction. For me, though, I don't think the extremes are accurate. There was a lot that was quite wonderful in it, and a lot that I didn't feel worked.
(In that regard, I was going to title this article, "Peter Panned," but I decided that that would be unfair and inaccurate for the sake of a good quip.)